Alastair sim, jack warner, kathleen harrison, hermione baddeley, ernest thesiger. Hear classic music from a christmas carol, 1951, directed by brian desmondhurst, with alastair sim, kathleen harrison, mervyn johns, at tcm. Both the british and american versions of this movie are on the emerald edition dvd. For many decades, this 1951 production was considered to be the best adaptation of charles dickens a christmas carol, and it is easy to see why. Ive long considered this 1951 jewel to be the very best film adaptation of charles dickens a christmas carol, and i first watched it in color on tcm a decade. I have, you see, been watching the many film versions there have been of the charles dickens classic in an endeavour to find the best movie adaptation of a christmas carol every year, around early december, i prepare myself for. Scrooge 1951 a christmas carol colorized alastair sim hosted. The right to be happy this 1916 silent movie was the first full length film version of a christmas carol, starring rupert julian in the scrooge role. Best movie adaptations of a christmas carol thetoptens. It stars alastair sim as ebenezer scrooge, and was produced and directed by brian desmond hurst, with a screenplay by noel langley. The classic 1951 portrayal of a christmas carol by charles dickens, also known as scrooge.
Scott and was directed by clive donner, who also edited a 1951 film version of the story titled scrooge. This movie is actually called scrooge and not a christmas carol. Aug 18, 2015 since the publication of a christmas carol, the story has never been out of print and has been adapted both for 22 stage productions, 2 operas, 4 recordings, at least 10 radio broadcasts, 49 loosely based tv show adaptations and 20 film versions. From the 1901 silent film called scrooge, or, marleys ghost to the 2009 full cgi 3d jim carrey version, a christmas carol is adapted for film, television, and stage perennially.
One dvd release features a version where the top and bottom of the frame were cropped so that the picture would fit on. A viewers guide to various versions of a christmas carol. Christmas spot memory lane mickeys christmas carol scrooge mcduck as ebenezer scrooge. The film version i have always watched is the 1951 adaptation starring alastair sim, largely because a i consider it the finest.
Oct 21, 2018 the classic charles dickens a christmas carol 1951 this film starred alistair sims as ebenezer scrooge hope you enjoy the video. A christmas carol, screen play by noel langley, from the story by charles dickens. A christmas carol 1951 starring alastair sim, meryvn johns, michael hordern and glyn dearman 86 min. Widely considered to be the definitive of the many film versions of charles dickens classic novel is this 1951 british adaptation, starring alastair sim entitled. After resentfully allowing timid clerk bob cratchit mervyn johns to have the holiday to spend with his loving wife hermione baddeley and family, scrooge is swept into a nightmare. A christmas carol full english full movie a christmas carol full full movie, a christmas carol full full movie streaming a christmas carol full movie engsub watch a christmas carol full english.
A christmas carol comparing and contrasting the 1951 and. Scrooge 1970 starring albert finney, sir alec guinness, edith evans and kenneth more. Scott, a christmas carol 1984 this lush madefortv version directed by clive donner, who edited the alastair sim version is anchored by a fearsome and funny turn by scott, who. Which version one buys is going to depend on what heshe specifically is looking for. I have collected many versions of this movie from the early vhs days to this new blue ray version. Alastair sims tourdeforce performance as the ultimate miser, ebenezer scrooge, has almost singlehandedly made this beloved version of charles dickens story into one of the bestloved. A christmas carol another silent movie version from the united kingdom, this 1923 film stars russell. A christmas carol 1951 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. It is the story of ebenezer scrooge, a greedy miser who hates christmas, but is transformed into a caring, kindly person through the visitations of four ghosts. A christmas carol 1951 movie mistakes, goofs and bloopers. A christmas carol 1951 60th anniversary diamond edition bluray us import the holiday picture of all time. In recent weeks ghosts, dozens maybe even thousands of them, have been appearing in my front room. Distributing a christmas carol hd, 10 minutes film distributor richard gordon reminisces about financing and marketing a christmas carol, and how producer george minter set out to make the definitive version of dickens classic.
Many of the christmas carol films have been animated versions of the scrooge tale. Sim plays ebenezer scrooge, a london miser who, despite his wealth, refuses to make charitable contributions and treats his sole employee, bob. Many adaptations of dickens christmas book have been and gone, but this is generally thought to be one of the definitive films of the story. This is the 1951 colorized version of scrooge, which aired on chicagos wgntv 9 in december of 1989, hosted by patrick macnee and includes all the original commercials. This is the most highly regarded version and the one most people think of when they say theyre going to watch a christmas carol. A christmas carol,1951, alastair sim as scrooge, movie. Some home video releases trim just a few seconds off the opening.
Scrooge 1951 a christmas carol colorized alastair sim. Ebenezer scrooge alastair sim malcontentedly shuffles through life as a cruel miserly businessman until one fateful christmas eve when he is visited by three spirits, sent show him how his unhappy childhood and maladaptive adult behavior over has let him a selfish, lonely, bitter old man. Alastair sim plays the definitive scooge, a conniving bully who unnerves everyone around him. Ebenezer scrooge, a curmudgeonly, miserly businessman, has no time for sentimentality and largely views christmas as a waste of time. Christmas spot the 1951 a christmas carol ultimate collectors edition on dvd. Directed by 1 writing credits 3 cast 42 produced by 2 music by 1 cinematography by 1 film editing by 1. Id advise anyone whos not seen it to come and know the 1951 version of a christmas carol. Scrooge 1951 a christmas carol colorized alastair sim hosted by patrick macnee. Being a history of a christmas carol on film by richard jones. Coming in at number one according to imdb s rankings it the 1951 classic a christmas carol or, in the united kingdom, scrooge starring alastair sim as a truly tough and merciless scrooge. Find low everyday prices and buy online for delivery or instore pickup. In the tradition of interpeting the classics, scrooge 1951 is another adaptation of. Because the movie ended up darker and more serious than other. Movie versions of a christmas carol readwritethink.
Much as sean connery is the only bond, alastair is the only scrooge for me. Scrooge released as a christmas carol in the united states is a 1951 british christmas fantasy drama film and an adaptation of charles dickens a christmas carol 1843. This 1984 madefortelevision version stars george c. Always interested in language especially the spoken word he became the fulton lecturer in elocution at new college, edinburgh university from 1925 until 1930. For many critics and fans, the 1951 film adaptation of dickenss a christmas carol, with british actor alastair sim in the titular role, is the definitive version. The classic work has been dramatised and adapted countless times for virtually every medium and performance. There have been umptydumpty film and television versions of dickenss most enduring story. Dec 24, 2017 scrooge renamed a christmas carol when it was released in america is widely considered the definitive cinema version of dickens novel.
While the film quality of a mid80s madefortv movie doesnt quite stand up on. An old bitter miser is given a chance for redemption when he is haunted by ghosts on christmas eve. Widely considered to be the definitive of the many film versions of charles dickens classic novel is this 1951 british adaptation, starring alastair sim entitled scrooge in its u. Scrooge renamed a christmas carol when it was released in america is widely considered the definitive cinema version of dickens novel. The son of alexander sim jp and isabella mcintyre, alastair sim was educated in edinburgh. A christmas carol 1951, hd alastair sim as scrooge. The voices alastair sim and michael hordern correspond to their same characters in the 1951 liveaction movie. A renown pictures presentation released here through united artists.
A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie versions. A christmas carol, 1951, alastair sim as scrooge, movie. The five best adaptations of a christmas carol screenwriter. A christmas carol is as much a part of the christmas tradition as santa claus and mistletoe, so its no surprise that this year theres yet another film version of the classic story. A christmas carol 1951 christmas movies on tv schedule. With the holiday season around the corner, i thought it would be a fun time to take a look at two filmed versions o f a christmas carol, and see how they stack up. For many critics and fans, the 1951 film adaptation of dickenss a christmas carol, with british actor alastair sim in the titular role, is the. Aug 07, 2017 \r\r\r\r\rscrooge 1951 is another british drama and film from the british school of film. The ghost of christmas past is played by a rather frail old man, undercutting those scenes, too. A christmas carol 1971 there are many outstanding animated versions of a christmas carol, and many more familyfriendly than this one, but the 1971 animated version of a christmas carol is. Brian desmond hurst by no means a director of renown. In the 1951 version one has to get past the fact that scrooges love interest is named alice instead of belle like the others. A christmas carol, british dramatic film, released in 1951, that is widely considered the best adaptation of charles dickenss classic tale of the same name. Find out if alternate versions exist for a christmas carol, 1951, directed by brian desmondhurst, with alastair sim, kathleen harrison, mervyn johns.
A christmas carol has been filmed many times, though this 1951 take on the tale remains the favorite of many a fan and critic. This 1951 version starring alastair sim in the title role, is my favorite version of all time. This film is perhaps one of the most adult of the adaptations, as it does not shy away from exploring the darker aspects of dickens original tale. A carol that hits all the top notes alastair sim and a superb supporting cast make this 1951 retelling of dickens classic the best ever committed to film. Dec 21, 2019 the many adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol ranked from worst to best, from a 1901 silent film to the 2009 computergenerated feature. The classic charles dickens a christmas carol 1951 this film starred alistair sims as ebenezer scrooge hope you enjoy the video. A christmas carol 1951 emerald edition crotchety victorian businessman ebenezer scrooge alastair sim has no use for festivity, even at christmas. A christmas carol 1954 this version starring fredric march as scrooge and basil rathbone as marleys ghost was broadcast in color in 1954.
Just how many versions of a christmas carol are there. The classic work has been dramatised and adapted countless. The following 49 pages are in this category, out of 49 total. He was invited back and became the rector of edinburgh university 1948 1951.
The 6 best a christmas carol movie adaptations ever, ranked. The 1951 adaptation of charles dickens timeless classic is perhaps the most faithful film version and alastair sims performance as scrooge is not to be. This 1951 version of a christmas carol is said to be the best by many people. In great britain, the film was released with the title scrooge and changed to a christmas carol for its united states release. Movie versions a christmas carol 1938 starring reginald owen, gene lockhart, kathleen lockhart, june lockhart, leo g. Charles dickens christmas carol and scrooge ced web page. A christmas carol movie tv listings and schedule tv guide. With alastair sim, jack warner, kathleen harrison, mervyn johns. Of course, there are many more versions of a christmas carol too many to list here. A christmas carol, the popular 1843 novella by charles dickens 18121870, is one of the british authors bestknown works. The best and worst adaptations features we delve back into more than a century of a christmas carol movies to find the best and. Ultimately, its a flawed script rescued by topnotch acting.
Just as the ghost of christmas past advised ebenezer scrooge to come and know him better, id advise anyone whos not seen it to come and know the 1951 version of a christmas carol. This category is for all film adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol, in either theater or television movie form. A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie. A christmas carol the most frightening and memorable. It began airing on bbc one in the united kingdom on 22 december 2019, and concluded two days later on 24 december 2019.
However, this christmas eve he will be visited by three spirits who will show him the errors of his ways. The many adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol ranked from worst to best, from a 1901 silent film to the 2009 computergenerated feature. The film version i have always watched is the 1951 adaptation starring alastair sim, largely because a i consider it the. Dec 22, 2016 in 2009 robert zemeckis directed a beautifully animated and acted version of a christmas carol. It is a perennial favourite at christmastime, when it is frequently broadcast on television. The biggest mistakes you never noticed in a christmas carol 1951. There are some really good cartoon versions, including the muppets christmas carol, which is. Charles dickens a christmas carol and scrooge this ced feature focuses on the three versions of charles dickens a christmas carol available on ced, but in a break with tradition, im expanding the scope of the feature to cover all the visual performances of the dickens tale about which information is still available. Scrooge is a 1951 british christmas fantasy drama film and an adaptation of charles dickens a christmas carol 1843. The threepart series is written by steven knight with actor tom hardy and ridley scott among the executive producers filming locations include rainham hall in. A christmas carol adaptations ranked from worst to best.
81 944 644 71 611 419 671 971 429 527 1588 579 427 1227 476 859 534 690 308 1465 777 221 1555 1210 1055 1497 1383 917 1061 206 200 359 1500 752 245 1251 306 778 1023 387 374